Pros and Cons of Donating Retirement Assets to Charity

Donating retirement assets to charity can be a powerful way to support causes you care about while potentially reaping tax benefits. However, donating retirement assets to charity, and other essential charitable gifting strategies, come with advantages and drawbacks that are important for retirees to consider.

Pros:

• Potential tax benefits
• Ability to make a significant impact on charitable causes
• Reduction of estate tax liability for heirs
• Opportunity to leave a lasting legacy

Cons:

• Reduced retirement income for yourself
• Potential impact on beneficiaries’ inheritance
• Complexity in execution and paperwork
• Irrevocable nature of the donation

In this article, we’ll explore each of these points, explaining how donating retirement assets to charity can affect your financial planning, contribute to your philanthropic goals, and possibly benefit your taxes.

What are the benefits of charitable giving from IRAs and other retirement accounts?

1. Potential tax benefits

Are donations from retirement accounts tax deductible? For donations made to retirement accounts other than an IRA or by those under 70½, you would typically need to withdraw the funds first (which would be taxable), and then donate them. In this case, you may be able to claim a charitable tax deduction for the donation, subject to IRS limits and whether you itemize deductions on your tax return.

If you’re 70½ or older and make a qualified charitable distribution (QCD) directly from your IRA to a charity, the amount is excluded from your taxable income and therefore isn’t tax-deductible. This exclusion can be more valuable than a deduction, as it can reduce your adjusted gross income (AGI).

It’s important to consult with a tax professional to understand the specific tax implications based on your individual circumstances and the type of retirement account you’re donating from. A tax advisor will also be able to help you take advantage of tax strategies like bunching charitable donations.

Learn more: How do donations affect taxes?

2. Ability to make a significant impact on charitable causes

Retirement accounts often represent a considerable portion of an individual’s wealth. By donating these assets, you can make a more substantial contribution to your chosen charity than you might be able to with cash donations from your current income. 

This larger gift can have a larger impact on the charitable causes you support, potentially funding major initiatives or long-term programs.

3. Reduction of estate tax liability for heirs

For those with sizable estates, donating retirement assets to charity can help reduce the estate tax burden on your heirs. Retirement accounts left to non-spouse beneficiaries are subject to both income and estate taxes, which can significantly reduce the amount your heirs actually receive. 

By donating these assets to charity instead, you can reduce the size of your taxable estate while planning for the full value of your contributions to go to your chosen cause.

4. Opportunity to leave a lasting legacy

Donating retirement assets allows you to create a lasting legacy that extends beyond your lifetime. Whether you choose to support educational institutions, medical research, environmental causes, or community organizations, your contribution can continue to make a difference for years to come. Additionally, many charities offer naming opportunities or establish endowments for significant gifts, which can help ensure that your philanthropic impact lives on.

What are the disadvantages of donating retirement assets?

1. Reduced retirement income for yourself

When you donate retirement assets to charity, you’re effectively reducing the funds available for your own use during retirement. This can be a significant drawback, especially if your retirement income planning hasn’t accurately planned for your long-term financial needs. 

It’s crucial to carefully assess your retirement income requirements so that you’re not compromising your own financial security in pursuit of philanthropic goals.

2. Potential impact on beneficiaries’ inheritance

Donating retirement assets to charity means those assets won’t be available to pass on to your heirs. This has the potential to significantly reduce the inheritance you leave for your loved ones. 

While some may view this as an opportunity to encourage self-reliance in their heirs, others might find it conflicts with their estate planning goals. It’s important to communicate your intentions with your family and consider how this decision aligns with your overall legacy plans.

3. Complexity in execution and paperwork

The process of donating retirement assets to charity can be more complex than simple cash donations. It often involves working with your IRA administrator, the receiving charity, and potentially legal and financial advisors to ensure the transfer is executed correctly. 

There may be specific forms to complete and rules to follow, particularly if you’re using a charitable deduction from an IRA. This complexity can be daunting and may require professional assistance to navigate properly.

4. Irrevocable nature of the donation

Once you’ve made a donation of retirement assets to a charity, the decision is typically irrevocable. Unlike some other forms of planned giving, you can’t change your mind or adjust the gift if your financial circumstances change. This lack of flexibility could be problematic if you face unexpected financial challenges in the future or if your philanthropic priorities shift over time.

Can a charity be a beneficiary of an IRA and other retirement assets?

Another approach to donating retirement assets to charity is to name a charitable organization as a beneficiary of your retirement account. This strategy offers some unique advantages:

• Flexibility: Unlike making direct donations during your lifetime, naming a charity as a beneficiary allows you to retain control of your assets while you’re alive. You can change your charitable beneficiary designation if your circumstances or priorities change.
• Simplicity: Designating a charity as a beneficiary is often as simple as filling out a beneficiary designation form provided by your retirement account administrator. This can be less complex than setting up lifetime donations.
• Tax efficiency: When a charity inherits a traditional IRA or 401(k), it doesn’t pay income tax on the distributions. This means the full amount of your retirement asset goes to the charity, unlike when an individual inherits these accounts and must pay income tax on distributions.
• Estate tax benefits: The amount left to charity will be deducted from your taxable estate, potentially reducing estate taxes for your heirs.
• Partial designations: You can name a charity as a beneficiary for a percentage of your retirement account, leaving the rest to individual heirs. This allows you to balance your philanthropic goals with providing for your loved ones.
• Donor-advised fund option: While you cannot make a QCD to a donor-advised fund, you can name a donor-advised fund as a beneficiary, allowing your heirs to have ongoing involvement in charitable giving decisions after your passing.

When considering whether or not to donate an IRA to charity, it’s important to coordinate your beneficiary designations with your overall estate plan. Consult with an estate planning attorney and your financial advisor to help you decide if your charitable giving strategy aligns with your other financial and legacy goals.

Wondering how donating your retirement assets will affect your financial plan? Let’s talk.

Donating retirement assets to charity can greatly contribute to your philanthropic goals and provide many tax benefits, but it needs to fit into your overall financial plan. For high-net-worth individuals, this means creating a nuanced approach that balances generosity with personal financial security and legacy goals.

At Avidian Wealth Solutions, we offer retirement planning for high-net-worth individuals who want to make a lasting impact through their giving. Our team of financial professionals can help you navigate the complexities of donating retirement assets so that your charitable intentions align with your broader financial objectives. 

Schedule a conversation with us today to learn more about our strategies for charitable retirement planning in Houston, Austin, Sugar Land, and The Woodlands.

More Helpful Articles by Avidian: 

• How Can Entrepreneurs Prepare For Risk Taking in Business?
• What is Financial Planning?
• The Importance of Buy-Sell Agreements for Business Owners
• Pensions vs. 401(k) Plans
• What is Tax Planning for High-Net-Worth Individuals?

---

Please read important disclosures here