Net Unrealized Appreciation: How Does it Work?

Company stock sitting in your 401(k) can feel like a mixed blessing — it represents years of corporate success and personal wealth building, but it can also create a complicated tax situation when you’re ready to access those funds. 

Net unrealized appreciation (NUA) is a tax strategy that applies to employer stock held within qualified retirement plans, such as 401(k)s. Rather than rolling over all retirement assets into an IRA, NUA allows individuals to distribute company stock in-kind to a taxable brokerage account. For ultra-high-net-worth families, evaluating whether this approach aligns with broader wealth management goals requires careful analysis of individual circumstances.

Schedule a conversation with Avidian Wealth Solutions to explore whether net unrealized appreciation might be worth considering as part of your comprehensive financial strategy.

How does net unrealized appreciation work?

Any distribution of employer stock from a qualified retirement plan contains two components: 

1. The cost basis (what the stock was worth when originally contributed to or purchased by your plan)
2. The appreciation (the increase in value from that original cost basis to the distribution date)

This appreciation, locked in at the distribution date, is your net unrealized appreciation. For example, if you receive a distribution of employer stock now valued at $500,000 with a cost basis of $50,000, the $450,000 difference represents your NUA.

When you distribute the stock in-kind to a taxable brokerage account rather than rolling it to an IRA, you pay ordinary income tax only on the cost basis at the time of distribution. The NUA remains untaxed until you sell the shares. When you do sell, that NUA receives long-term capital gains treatment regardless of how long you’ve held the stock outside the plan. Any additional appreciation beyond the NUA gets taxed as either a short-term or long-term capital gain, depending on your actual holding period after distribution.

Using the net unrealized appreciation example above, consider the following hypothetical situation:

if you sell the stock ten years later when it’s worth $750,000…

• You’d pay long-term capital gains tax on both the $450,000 NUA and the additional $250,000 appreciation.
• The $50,000 cost basis, already taxed at distribution, faces no additional taxation at sale.

Qualifying for NUA: What is a lump-sum distribution?

NUA tax treatment is generally available only when you receive employer securities as part of a lump-sum distribution. To qualify, two conditions must be met: 

1. You must receive your entire balance within a single tax year from all of your employer’s qualified plans of the same type (all pension plans, all profit-sharing plans, or all stock bonus plans).
2. The distribution must occur after you reach age 59½, after separation from service, or after death.

There’s one exception worth noting: Even if your distribution doesn’t meet the lump-sum requirement, securities distributed from the plan that were purchased with your after-tax (non-Roth) contributions may still be eligible for this tax treatment.

Estate planning considerations: NUA is for beneficiaries, too

The net unrealized appreciation tax treatment extends to your beneficiaries if you die while still holding employer securities in your retirement plan. If your beneficiary receives a lump-sum distribution, the taxation generally mirrors what you would have faced — the stock doesn’t receive a step-up in basis simply because it passes at death.

However, if you’ve already taken the distribution, elected NUA treatment, and die before selling the stock, the tax dynamics shift favorably. Your heir will pay long-term capital gains tax on the NUA when selling, but any appreciation beyond the NUA as of your date of death receives a step-up in basis and escapes taxation entirely. 

For example, if you took a distribution with $450,000 in NUA and the stock appreciates another $250,000 before your death, that $250,000 appreciation would be tax-free to your heirs. This feature can make NUA particularly relevant when considering multigenerational wealth transfer strategies.

When does NUA make sense?

NUA tax strategy advice typically points toward individuals with substantial appreciation relative to a small cost basis, but the decision involves multiple intersecting factors. Understanding when this strategy aligns with your situation requires examining several key conditions:

Large appreciation relative to cost basis

The larger the spread between your cost basis and current value, the more compelling the potential tax savings become. When net unrealized appreciation is explained in practical terms, the strategy delivers the most value when you have significant appreciation that can be converted from ordinary income tax treatment to capital gains rates. 

If your employer stock has appreciated substantially over your career, the differential between these tax rates can represent considerable savings. Understanding how this differs from a traditional IRA rollover helps clarify the opportunity. 

With an IRA rollover, you defer all taxation until you take distributions, but those distributions face ordinary income tax rates at every level. With NUA, you accept immediate ordinary income tax on the cost basis but convert future appreciation to capital gains treatment.

Current and future tax rate analysis

The tradeoff becomes more complex when considering other strategies like a 401(k) Roth conversion, which involves paying taxes now in exchange for tax-free growth. Each approach — NUA, traditional IRA rollover, or Roth conversion — serves different goals depending on current versus anticipated future tax rates, time horizon, and estate planning objectives.

If you expect to be in a higher tax bracket in retirement, or if you anticipate capital gains rates increasing, the timing of when you pay taxes and at what rate becomes a critical variable in the analysis. For those in peak earning years facing top marginal rates, deferring the majority of taxation through an IRA rollover might seem appealing, yet the long-term capital gains treatment available through NUA could ultimately result in lower lifetime tax liability.

Estate planning and wealth transfer goals

For ultra-high-net-worth families, estate planning goals often drive the NUA decision. If you’ve already taken the distribution, elected NUA treatment, and die before selling the stock, your heirs benefit from a unique tax advantage: they’ll pay long-term capital gains tax when selling, but any appreciation after your date of death receives a step-up in basis and avoids other taxation. This feature can make NUA particularly relevant when considering multigenerational wealth transfer strategies as part of comprehensive retirement planning services.

Portfolio diversification and risk management

Concentration risk deserves careful attention before electing NUA. Holding substantial employer stock may not align with prudent portfolio management, particularly for those also considering investing in alternative assets for their 401(k) or building a more diversified approach to business retirement planning. The tax benefits of NUA must be weighed against the risk of having significant wealth concentrated in a single company’s stock.

It’s worth noting that you don’t face an all-or-nothing decision. You can roll a portion of your employer stock to an IRA and apply NUA treatment to the rest. If your distribution includes cash in addition to stock, you can roll the cash to an IRA separately while handling the stock according to your chosen strategy. This flexibility allows you to balance tax optimization with appropriate diversification.

Timing, age, and penalty considerations

Your age at the time of distribution affects both eligibility and potential penalties. If you’re not yet age 55 at separation from service (or 59½ for other triggering events), you may face a 10% early distribution penalty on the cost basis portion of your distribution. This penalty can significantly erode the tax benefits of the strategy, making it less attractive for those separating from service in their 40s or early 50s.

For some individuals, particularly those born before 1936, other special tax rules may apply that could make different distribution strategies more favorable. The analysis becomes more nuanced for ultra-high-net-worth families who may benefit from coordinating NUA decisions with trust planning and charitable giving strategies.

Additional factors to consider

Several other factors warrant careful evaluation before committing to this strategy. First, the decision is irrevocable — once you roll employer stock into an IRA, you permanently forfeit the NUA opportunity. Second, employer stock held in a qualified retirement plan or IRA receives significant creditor protection that disappears when you hold shares in a taxable brokerage account.

State tax implications can further affect the analysis, as some states tax capital gains differently than others. The interplay between federal and state taxation, combined with your specific financial situation, requires modeling various scenarios to understand the true impact of each approach on your retirement income solutions.

Evaluate your options with Avidian’s wealth advisors

Given the complexity and irrevocable nature of net unrealized appreciation elections, determining whether this strategy aligns with your situation requires personalized analysis that goes beyond general guidelines.

Avidian Wealth Solutions works with ultra-high-net-worth families in Houston, Austin, Sugar Land, and The Woodlands to evaluate complex retirement distribution strategies within the context of comprehensive financial planning. Our team can help you model various scenarios, compare NUA against alternative approaches, and determine whether this strategy aligns with your specific goals.

Schedule a conversation with our advisors to discuss whether net unrealized appreciation merits consideration as part of your retirement income and wealth transfer strategy.

Disclaimer – This information is provided for educational purposes only and should not be construed as individualized tax or investment advice. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. Individuals should consult with their tax and financial advisors regarding their specific circumstances.

More Helpful Articles by Avidian: 

• Unique Careers that Require Special Financial Planning
• Is the Future of Wealth Female?
• A Brief Overview of the 1033 Exchange Rule
• How to Manage Crypto Risk With a CRUT
• Investing in AI Stocks vs. AI Users

---

Please read important disclosures here